• Jakob Nielsen: The Want Interview

    Jakob Nielsen by Ken Grobe May 14, 2010
    • Share

    I can list several reasons why my Editor-In-Chief and I high-fived each other after our interview with Dr. Jakob Nielsen. Granted, Nielsen is one of the few “celebrities” of the Usability trade, that rare author/expert known outside the UX community who is interviewed by mainstream publications and even called “The guru of Web page usability” by no less an authority than the New York Times.

    The fact that he was kind enough to talk to us three times longer than the time span he allotted for us didn’t hurt either. But I’d say the high-five largely came from an appreciation of Nielsen’s ability to look at the field of UX with a scope of knowledge and understanding matched by few.

    Nielsen started his career as a usability engineer pre-Web, in 1983, to be exact. We asked him how the field of UX—and its older brother, Human Computer Interaction (HCI)—has changed in that span of time. Once again, He went the extra mile for us, outlining the history of the field by splitting it into two cycles: product focus and sheer growth.

    Cycle One: From Applications to Apps

    Nielsen charted one cycle of interface design from the 1940s, with the design of airplane cockpits and nuclear power plant control panels–—essentially, interface design for applications. When Nielsen started his career almost three decades ago, application interfaces—albeit for computer software—remained the discipline.

    Fast-forward to the 90s and early 2000s, when web design gave us new interfaces to contend with, forcing the need to create and design new idioms and paradigms for navigation and use.

    Less than a decade later, as our digital use strays from the desktop computer to mobile devices, the need for application design has returned to the forefront. “It’s really come full circle.” Nielsen explains. “With ad campaigns preaching that ‘There’s an app for that,’ comes a need for people who know how to make them usable.”

    Cycle Two: From Handfuls to Crowds of Experts

    In the second cycle, Nielsen charts the demand for UX talent—which has never been greater. “There’s been a very linear path in the influence and the size and the magnitude of usability work [and] of serious business attention to user experience.

    “Going back to my early career, there were just a handful of people like myself in the world–—several hundred [at most]. Most projects proceeded without any user testing–—without even the minimal amount of usability work. The design was done by the programmers as kind of a side effect of the implementation. Which, we know, leads to bad software, but that’s how it was done.

    “Today, we have tens of thousands of usability professionals, people who specialize purely in the research aspect of finding out what users need. We have hundreds of thousands of professional interface designers. But there’s still a lot of [interfaces] done just as a side effect of the implementation…by the programmers. Websites are [often] designed by sort of an HTML-coder kind of person or even a so-called interface designer who doesn’t really understand interaction design.

    “So, we’re not there, but the growth path has been immense. This field has grown by at least a factor of 1,000 in the time I’ve been doing this job.”

    UX: Growing By The Day

    The demand for usability continues to rise. “More and more,” Jacob assures us, “It’s the differentiating factor between different products and different websites.”

    That factor makes sense, given the amount of competition out there. By Nielsen’s rough (but probably conservative) estimates, “There are, I think, about 300 million websites in the world, several hundred thousand software applications, and a handful of mobile phone companies, and so forth.” Lump in the amount of companies that build interface-dependent products (phones or consumer electronics, anyone?) and you have a lot of demand for a user interface that shifts units.

    Can Usability Buy Happiness?

    While that’s good news for professional UX-perts and magazines looking to appeal to that audience (ahem), it’s even better news for consumers—as Nielsen points out from his own experience:

    “I just bought a camera, and the first thing that happens when opening the box? It says, ‘Stop. If you cannot figure out how to use this camera, do not return it. Call our customer support line.’

    “They know their camera is bad.” Nielsen says, shaking his head in disbelief. “They know consumers can’t use it. And then they have a high cost of return product and a high cost of support calls. They could just hire a few usability people and make it easy instead.”

    The Rise Of The Amateur

    Nielsen also anticipates an increase in “amateur” usability, a phrase he does not see as derogatory. Rather, he defines it as people for whom usability is only a part of their skill set and/or paycheck.

    “Designers,” He uses as an example, “Should do a lot of their own usability. Same for a lot of market research and business managers, and so forth.”

    And they’ll have plenty to keep them busy: “There’s not going to be enough full-time professionals–really seasoned, experienced people–to cover all these websites and hundreds of thousands of complex applications and all of that.”

    With more and more daily-use objects becoming digital, increased focus on better UX comes not a moment too soon. While books, music and photos come first to mind, Nielsen gave us an example of a physical, industrial product with a renewed need for interface design: cars.

    “BMW, for many years, received consistently bad reviews for a control device, called the iDrive, that was very difficult to use. That’s software design, it’s screen design, it’s interaction design–it’s not just car design. [BMW] can’t just take people who are good at building fast cars and assume that those guys can make a great complex menu hierarchy.”

    The Engineering Of Want

    We asked Nielsen the question on which we’ve based this issue’s theme: How can “want” be one engineered “want” into a product or service. Ever a numbers-over-instinct man, he refused to buy into the idea that an audience’s “want” can be gauged by anything other than methodical testing.

    “Let me first say what I do not do, and that’s to just ask people what they want…people don’t know what they want. What they say and what they do are very often different things.

    “The average person’s great ability is that they are the average person—they are the customer; they are the user—what they do rules, but only what they do, not what they say they do.”

    How to instill want? In the mind of Jakob Nielsen, you figure out what your audience wants, and design towards that. As advice goes, it doesn’t get much more user-friendly than that.

    Image of Eyetracking Web Usability
    Image of Prioritizing Web Usability
    Image of Homepage Usability: 50 Websites Deconstructed
    Image of Designing Web Usability

    This website uses IntenseDebate comments, but they are not currently loaded because either your browser doesn't support JavaScript, or they didn't load fast enough.

    30 Responses to “Jakob Nielsen: The Want Interview”

    1. Jakob Nielsen: The Want Interview. What more needs be said? #ux #uxlx http://want.by/aPxjVV

    2. "what they do rules, but only what they do, not what they say they do" #ux http://want.by/aPxjVV

    3. chess says:

      en @wantmag, entrevista con jakob nielsen (cc @baldiri) http://bit.ly/aufpuH

    4. grupologin says:

      Interessante a entrevista de Jacob Nielsen na Want Magazine – http://wantmag.com/release/001/2010/05/jakob-nielsen/

    5. RT @wantmag: Jakob Nielsen: The Want Interview #ux http://want.by/aPxjVV

    6. Interessante a entrevista de Jacob Nielsen na Want Magazine – http://wantmag.com/release/001/2010/05/jakob-nielsen/

    7. Tammy says:

      I have added this article to stumbledupon

      Live Chat — asexygf.com

    8. [...] на сайте журнала вы сможете посмотреть интервью с Якобом Нильсеном, Биллом Скоттом, Питером Мерхольцем и [...]

    9. Laert Jansen says:

      RT @wantmag: Jakob Nielsen: The Want Interview #ux http://want.by/aPxjVV

    10. Laert Jansen says:

      RT @wantmag: Jakob Nielsen: The Want Interview #ux http://want.by/aPxjVV

    11. RT @laertjansen: RT @wantmag: Jakob Nielsen: The Want Interview #ux http://want.by/aPxjVV

    12. STC UUX says:

      One trend; the rise of the amateur #ux designer: RT @laertjansen: RT @wantmag: Jakob Nielsen: The Want Interview http://want.by/aPxjVV

    13. Fascinating interview of Don Norman – http://bit.ly/dZjn41 The overlap of #UX, #Design, #Advertising & #Marketing

    14. RT @sandraniehaus: Fascinating interview of Don Norman – http://bit.ly/dZjn41 The overlap of #UX, #Design, #Advertising & #Marketing

    15. Eric Briand says:

      RT @sandraniehaus: Fascinating interview of Don Norman – http://bit.ly/dZjn41 The overlap of #UX, #Design, #Advertising & #Marketing

    16. Wim Rampen says:

      Don Norman: The Want Interview http://t.co/AomitgW via @BrianSJ3

    17. Syamant says:

      RT @wimrampen: Don Norman: The Want Interview http://t.co/AomitgW via @BrianSJ3

    18. Don Norman: The Want Interview http://j.mp/eltWlz #ux #hci #video

    19. Meikel says:

      RT @preciousforever: Don Norman: The Want Interview http://j.mp/eltWlz #ux #hci #video

    20. Dolly says:

      I feel so much happier now I udnetrsand all this. Thanks!

    21. Erico Fileno says:

      Jakob Nielsen interview in Want Magazine http://goo.gl/OTJA0 #ux

    22. Jakob Nielsen interview in Want Magazine http://goo.gl/OTJA0 #ux

    23. #UX Jakob Nielsen interview in Want Magazine http://goo.gl/OTJA0 (via @efileno )

    24. David Travis says:

      Good Jakob Nielsen video interview — but ironically the adverts embedded in the video create an AWFUL #ux. http://bit.ly/iRwcfz

    25. Good Jakob Nielsen video interview — but ironically the adverts embedded in the video create an AWFUL #ux. http://bit.ly/iRwcfz

    26. [...] Over a year ago Want Magazine interviewed Jakob Nielsen about his thoughts on experience design and usability, where it has came from and where it is heading. The interview begins with Nielsen explaining the usability industry pre web and his experiences since 1983. Since then Nielsen says the industry has seen immense growth though he admits that many of the interactions and interfaces on the web today are still being designed by programmers and HTML competent individuals. Nielsen stresses the importance of a great experience on the web as this may be the deciding factor between buying a product or leaving for a competitors website. He cautions that in the traditional world first you buy a product followed by the experience but in the online world the experience is to the fore and then after all of these user interface steps the money is paid. There is an article about the conversation on the Want website you can find here. [...]

    27. Anna Homs says:

      This really is such a fantastic resource that youre providing and you give it absent for free. I love seeing web sites that comprehend the worth of offering a top quality resource free of charge. It?s the outdated what goes about comes around routine.

    Leave a Reply